The Wall Street Journal

Security Expert Breaks Down How White House Documents Are Stored


The transcript of President Trump's call with Ukraine shed light on a method for classifying documents that's even more top secret than top secret. WSJ spoke to a former National Security Council official to understand the intricacies of the White House server security system.

#WSJ #Trump #Trumpscall

Adrian Wojnarowski joins Mike Greenberg on Get Up to report on breaking news surrounding Anthony Davis' 5-year/$190M contract with the Los Angeles Lakers and breaks down how the Houston Rockets and Washington Wizards came to terms on a deal for Russell Westbrook and John Wall.
#NBA #GetUp
Current and former White House officials are already planning their next moves ahead of President Trump's departure next week. But some are already facing backlash for their association with his administration. Vanity Fair special correspondent William Cohan calls this the "Trump Stink." He joined CBSN'S Lana Zak to discuss.

CBSN is CBS News' 24/7 digital streaming news service featuring live, anchored coverage available for free across all platforms. Launched in November 2014, the service is a premier destination for breaking news and original storytelling from the deep bench of CBS News correspondents and reporters. CBSN features the top stories of the day as well as deep dives into key issues facing the nation and the world. CBSN has also expanded to launch local news streaming services in major markets across the country. CBSN is currently available on and the CBS News app across more than 20 platforms, as well as the CBS All Access subscription service.
White House security confirmed they are looking into a potential computer hack threatening national security. NBC News' Josh Lederman reports on what information could be at stake.
President Trump and Vice President Mike Pence have met for the first time since the Capitol riot. And acting Homeland Security Secretary Chad Wolf resigned from his position in the final days of the Trump administration. CBS News White House producer Fin Gomez joins "CBSN AM" with more details.

… show captions ↓
- [Narrator] When a president does anything,
like, make a simple phone call,
the Presidential Records Act says it has to be recorded.
Twitter DMs, sticky notes and all.
Kelly Magsamen
is a former National Security Council official
under both Presidents Bush and Obama.
During her experience in the White House,
every call by the president included an involved process
to keep all of this information in the right place.
- There are basically three main systems that NSC staff use.
First is the unclassified system,
which we like to refer to as the low side.
There is a secret system which we call sipper,
which is used essentially to communicate
with State Department and Pentagon,
people outside of the National Security Council.
And then there's the top secret system
that is used on day-to-day basis by most of the NSC staff.
And then there's a separate,
which you're seeing in the press,
codeword system and server that is completely distinct,
that most NSC staff have no access to,
physical or otherwise.
- [Narrator] In the context of President Trump
and his phone call with the President of Ukraine,
this is the important detail to pay attention to.
There are three normal and secure systems
for most information.
But one, as Magsamen described,
Mission Impossible-level, codeword-only system.
Wall Street Journal reporting shows
that system is where the rough transcript
of this phone call ended up.
And both former White House and NSC officials are concerned
that misclassification was used as a way
to hide politically damaging information,
and not national security information.
The White House says that they're still grappling
with the implications of the complaint.
- The way that these call memorandums work is
every single sentence or paragraph carries
a classification based on whatever's in it.
So, when the President picks up the phone and says,
"Hi Vladimir, how are you doing today?"
That'd be unclassified,
'cause it's not containing any classified information.
Then the next paragraph could be something
that's at the confidential level,
so for example,
"Hi Vladimir, I wanted to get your opinion
"on our latest trade agreement."
Even on a secret level, secret is usually things
that are highly sensitive,
maybe you're in the middle of a negotiation,
maybe there's potential discussion of military operations.
Most presidential calls are classified
at most really around the secret level.
- [Narrator] From the moment the President picks
up the phone, to all of those classifications being made,
there are usually at least three people listening in,
transcribing everything they hear.
Sometimes, NSC subject matter experts are on the call too,
like the NSC Director for that particular country.
They make up a unified draft
that's reviewed by officials in the NSC Directorate
and the White House Situation Room
to refine, review for substance, classify
and even just to spell check.
It goes to the National Security Advisor's office
for a final review and sign off,
and after that it's off
to the Executive Secretary of the National Security Council
to be distributed to whomever is cleared
and needs that information.
- If the President of the United States were discussing
top secret codeword information with a foreign leader,
whoever is transcribing the notes would not be transcribing
it on a normal system,
because codeword is our tippy top, most secret
intelligence programs.
Very unlikely, if not impossible,
that the President of the United States is discussing
codeword information with a foreign counterpart.
So to begin with, this is not normal, it wouldn't happen.
But if he had been,
it would've been on a completely different system,
and the people who are able to handle
that information would have to have special clearances.
- [Narrator] Special clearances
to just that one program being discussed.
That system is so secure that even if someone gets access,
and is read into hypothetical codeword alpha material,
it doesn't mean that they can simply access other material
about hypothetical codeword beta on the same system.
codeword clearance is as close to total information lockdown
as you can get.
So if phone calls by the President are classified at best,
where in the process did the Ukraine call go
from being placed on the regular systems
to the Mission Impossible-level codeword systems?
- I suspect that it was treated as a normal call,
the White House Situation Room clearly produced
the transcript,
several people in the NSC staff had a chance
to review that transcript,
so my guess is that the decision was made
to put in on a codeword server
at the National Security Advisor's level,
potentially the NSC Chief of Staff,
kind of at the third rung of the process,
and then that information was transferred
to a codeword server.
But that information was not codeword.
- [Narrator] The White House did not respond to comment
on when the material was put on the codeword server,
but says that the justification was to avoid more leaks.
- The American public has to have confidence
in their national security system and process.
And there have been times in history
where that trust has been broken.
We saw this in the Iran-Contra affair
where there was obfuscation of material,
hiding of material from the American public, lying about it.
These classifications exist to protect,
intelligence sources and methods are
our biggest crown jewels,
they are not meant to protect political wrongdoing,
corruption and certainly not meant
to protect criminal activity.
(dramatic music)

Share Video:

Embed Video: