How China's Tariffs Could Disrupt Tesla's Recent Progress
Higher import tariffs in China and other challenges could offset Tesla's recent ratings upgrade and its improved outlook for Model 3 production.
Photo illustration: Laura Kammermann
#WSJ #Tesla #TradeWar
Several million miles traveled and weeks spent in the vacuum of space. China's Chang'e-5 lunar mission successfully ended with the retrieval of its capsule containing the first samples returned from the moon in over 40 years. See it unfold. With COVID-19 numbers getting worse, a vaccine can't come soon enough. But there is concern that rich people anxious for inoculation will turn to buying them from the black market. Millions of doses of the vaccine are being stored in giant distribution hubs, including one in Chicago. They're under very tight security as they await emergency approval from the FDA, which is expected to come Dec. 15. Concierge doctor Abe Malkin says some corporations may try to game the system for clients as well. With the largest land mass of any country in the world, Russia is positioned to benefit from climate change, according to a new report by New York Times Magazine and ProPublica. Abrahm Lustgarten, the author of that report, joins CBSN to explain. CNBC.com's MacKenzie Sigalos brings you the day's top business news headlines. On today's show, CNBC's Eunice Yoon reports from Beijing on the state of life and commerce in China exactly one year after a Wuhan doctor first raised a flag about Covid-19. Plus, CNBC.com's Leslie Josephs breaks down the industry outlook for airlines in 2021 after a disastrous 2020.
00:00 -- Intro
0:44 -- Stocks set to close out 2020 with solid gains
1:50 -- State of Chinese economy one year after a doctor first flagged mystery virus
4:46 -- CNBC Soundcheck
6:23 -- Tarmac or Takeoff?
9:39 -- Numbers Round
(light electronic music) - After falling below Wall Street's earnings expectations in July, Tesla got a short-term boost. Moody's Investor Service recently raised the company's outlook from negative to stable, largely because Tesla met its production goals on the Model 3. But the ratings upgrade is being eclipsed by higher import tariffs in China. China's retaliatory tariffs on about 75 billion dollars worth of goods take effect on September 1st and on December 15th. They apply to a wide range of products like clothing, chemicals, agricultural goods and automobiles. As one of the major car companies building a significant number of vehicles in the U.S. for export to China, Tesla could be hit hard. China is a critical part of Tesla's long-term strategy, being Tesla's second biggest market in terms of revenue. The company touts itself as the next great growth company, betting that demand in China, now the world's largest electric car market, will rise significantly and eventually pay off. But the tariff hikes could hurt demand and Tesla's sales in China since Tesla may be forced to raise prices. - It's really not a great time to be expanding a new business into China. Tensions are escalating, it's a very fluid situation with President Trump and President Xi. The trouble is if you're planning a business, you need months and even years of lead time to do a proper expansion, and we don't have any clarity on what the next couple hours are gonna look like. - [Narrator] To save costs and improve margins amid rising demand in China, Tesla borrowed a half a billion dollars to build a new car plant in Shanghai. The tariffs will come just as Tesla completes construction, with Model 3 production scheduled to start by the end of the year. During Tesla's second quarter earnings call in July, Tesla CEO Elon Musk continued to promote the company as a paragon of growth. - [Elon] We expect growth to continue in the future at, for several years to come, at the 50% to 100% level. - [Narrator] But Musk's enthusiasm doesn't match up with the market reality. Tesla sales around the world, including China, are slowing, not growing. And U.S. sales are expected to be down for the year and fall short of the 17 million mark for the first time since 2014. And demand for Teslas is likely to slow, since U.S. federal tax credits, once as high as $7,500 for Tesla buyers, expire at the end of this year. And Tesla's debt means the company has less cash for responding to those pressures. The company has never turned a profit. - Revenue growth is the way to keep the story going for Tesla, and in the third quarter coming up analysts expect sales to actually decline a little bit from a year earlier. Tesla needs to show that that slowdown is just a blip and that the future really is as bright as Elon Musk has claimed. - [Narrator] Another option is for Tesla to be less ambitious in terms of size and sales expectations. Tesla can thrive in the industry without dominating it. - There is a real viable business for Tesla in the long run selling super expensive cars to select buyers the way they started out, what got them their brand value in the first place. The trouble is that's a sustainable business, but it might not carry a big market value. Stock investors just won't be as interested in that as a mass market story.